Harpagophytum procumbens

Harpagophytum Procumbens (Devil's Claw) is a tuber that has traditional usage for musculoskeletal disorders, pain relief, and appetite stimulation; it appears to have preliminary evidence for its benefits to osteoarthritis and pain.

This page features 39 unique references to scientific papers.

Confused about supplements?


Free 5 day supplement course

Summary

All Essential Benefits/Effects/Facts & Information

Harpagophytum Procumbens (commonly called Devil's Claw) is a tuber vegetable that is used for combatting lower back pain as well as arthritis (both osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis). It appears to have efficacy at this, and may take a few months to reach maximal efficacy (so it would be unlikely something like Aspirin, which acts fairly fast).

Human trials have been conducted on Devil's Claw and arthritis, and although there appear to be a large amount of trials conducted on it many are not sourced online or in Medline (instead mentioned vicariously through systemic reviews and meta-analysis' on the subject) and the power of these trials are limited, due to sample sizes and lack of control for the most part. That being said, at least two well controlled trials note that the efficacy of Devil's Claw is greater than placebo with one saying it is of similar potency to Vioxx (Rofecoxib, a COX2 inhibitor and antiinflammatory).

Not too much research into other effects of Devil's Claw, although one study suggests it has remarkable anticholesterase inhibitory potential with the potency on butrylcholinesterase (a cholinesterase enzyme found in the blood and liver) being greater than Galantamine.

There appears to be much discussion on safety of Devil's Claw, which may have stemmed from traditional users of Devil's Claw warning about excessive usage. In short term trials it appears to be well tolerated, with a lack of long term evidence. It is definitely possible that it may induce uterine contractions when taken orally, and due to this it should not be used by pregnant women.

Confused about supplements?

Free 5 day supplement course

Things To Know

Also Known As

Devil's Claw, Grapple plant, Duiwelsklou, Wood Spider

Do Not Confuse With

Cat's Claw (Undaria Tomentosa)

Caution Notice

  • May induce uterine contractions, and contraindicted for usage during pregnancy

Examine.com Medical Disclaimer

How to Take

Recommended dosage, active amounts, other details

Studies conducted on humans using Devil's Claw tend to use a brand called Doloteffin, where 6,000mg of Devil's Claw root is taken daily which totals 50mg Harpagoside (tends to be used as an indicator of efficacy). It was taken in three divided doses, with 2,000mg taken at each of the three major meals.

Benefits of Devil's Claw extract, as it pertains to arthritis and inflammation, may take upwards of 1-4 months to achieve maximal efficacy.

Confused about supplements?

Free 5 day supplement course

Human Effect Matrix

The Human Effect Matrix looks at human studies (it excludes animal and in vitro studies) to tell you what effects harpagophytum procumbens has on your body, and how strong these effects are.

Grade Level of Evidence
Robust research conducted with repeated double-blind clinical trials
Multiple studies where at least two are double-blind and placebo controlled
Single double-blind study or multiple cohort studies
Uncontrolled or observational studies only
Level of Evidence
? The amount of high quality evidence. The more evidence, the more we can trust the results.
Outcome Magnitude of effect
? The direction and size of the supplement's impact on each outcome. Some supplements can have an increasing effect, others have a decreasing effect, and others have no effect.
Consistency of research results
? Scientific research does not always agree. HIGH or VERY HIGH means that most of the scientific research agrees.
Notes
Lower Back Pain Minor - See study
A decrease in back pain has been noted (with a greater frequency of pain abolishment than placebo) which needs to be replicated
Symptoms of Osteoarthritis Minor Very High See all 3 studies
Symptoms of osteoarthritis appear to be reduced following ingestion of devil's claw, but insufficient robust evidence exists


1Sources and Composition

1.1. Sources

Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens of the family Pedaliaceae) is an African herb that can be found in Namibia, Botswana, South Africa, Angola, Zambia, and Zimbabwe; traditional usage of Devil's Claw is as an analgesic, for fevers and allergies, appetite stimulation, wounds and skin rashes, dyspepsia, liver and kidney disorders, as diuretic and sedative, and to treat degenerative disorders of the musculoskeletal system[1][2] The dried tubers tend to be the active part of the plant used (specifically the secondary tubers, those that branch off the main stems),[3] despite the name of Devil's Claw being drawn from the fruits; the fruits of Harpagophytum procumbens tend to have two straight thorns and numerous characteristically long protrusions with sharp, grapple-like hooks.[3] Other names for this plant, Grapple plant and Duiwelsklou, also refer to these claw-like protrusions and the species name (Harpagophytum) is derived from Harpago, the Greek term for the grappling hook.[3] Some other names include Wood Spider.[4]

The herb Harpagophytum zeyheri is also sometimes referred to as Devil's Claw,[3] although it is lower in bioactives and is commonly seen as an adulterant.[5] The presence of the molecule known as 6-acetylacteoside can be used to detect the species, as it is present in Procumbens but absent in Zeyheri as can the ratio of 8-O-p-coumaroylharpagide to the sum of Harpagoside as it is below 10% in Procumbens yet higher than 31% in Zeyheri.[6]

Harpagophytum procumbens can be further divided into two subspecies; H. procumbens subsp. procumbens or H. procumbens subsp. transvaalense.[3]

Devil's Claw is a name given to the plant Harpagophytum procumbens due to the appearance of claws on the fruits; the storage form of the plant, the tubers, are used medicinally while the name is due to the fruits which are not used medicinally

1.2. Composition

Devil's Claw contains:

  • The simple Irioid Glycosides known as Harpagide and Procumbide[2]

  • Derivatives of Harpagide including Harpagoside (also known as 8-cinnamoylharpagide), 8-cinnamoylmyoporoside, 8-O-feruloylharpagide (1% of commercial extracts, 0.25% dry plant weight[7]), and (same glycoside) as well as Harprocumbide A and 6-O-alpha-D-galactopyranosylharpagoside (different glycosides)[2] and Pagide[8]

  • 8-O-(p-coumaroyl)-harpagide and 8-O-(cis-p-coumaroyl)-harpagide, built off Harpagide and both referred to by the acronym of 8-PCHG[2][3]

  • Derivatives of Procumbide including harprocumbide B and 6"-O-(p-coumaroyl)-procumbide[2]

  • Pagoside[9] and Methoxypagoside[10]

  • Decaffeoylverbascoside[10]

  • Pentacyclic saponins Nigaichigoside F1 and F2,[11][2] Chebuloside II,[11][2] and Harproside[8]

  • Phenolic/Phenylethanoid Glycosides such as Acteoside[12] (also known as Verbascoside, the main Phenylethanoid Glycoside[13] at up to 15.8% of ethanolic extracts or 2% plant dry weight[7]) and Isoacteoside (5% ethanolic extract[7]),[14] as well as 6-acetylacteoside, 6'-O-acetylacteoside (10% ethanolic extract[7]), 2'-O-Acetylacetoside (2% ethanolic extract[7]) 2,6-diacetylacteoside (3% ethanolic extract[7]),[15] Martynoside,[11][2][16] Leucosceptoside A and β-OH-verbascoside[17]

  • β-(3′,4′-dihydroxyphenyl)-O-α-rhamnopyranosyl(1→3)-β-d-glucopyranoside[14]

  • (+)-8,11,13-totaratriene-12,13-diol (built off of a totarane structure)[7][18]

  • (+)-8,11,13-abietatrien-12-ol (Ferruginol, built off of an abietane structure)[7][18] and 13-hydroxytotara-7,9,13-trien-6,12-dione (Maytenoquinone)[7]

  • Chinane-type tricyclic diterpenoids,[19] which have been noted to form a Diels-Adder product[7]

  • Cinnamic acid and Caffeic Acid[7][9]

  • 7α-hydroxysitosterol and 7β-hydroxysitosterol

When looking at Harpagoside, which is commonly seen as the molecule to assess for standardization and a biomarker of the medicinally efficacy of the plant, the secondary tubers appear to have twice as much Harpagoside as the primary tubers;[3] the flowers, fruits, and stems are seemingly absent while leaves have trace amounts.[3] The tubers tend to contain anywhere between 0.5-3% Irioid Glycosides (the class seen as bioactive)[20]

The active ingredient(s) is/are not fully established, but Harpagoside is commonly referred to as the active ingredient since products with Harpagoside are the same products with therapeutic efficacy. Due to this, Harpagoside is a marker of efficacy and is usually standardized to above 1.2% total weight
The phenylethanoid glycosides are most likely contributors to the therapeutic effects, since they are found in high quantities in the ethanolic extracts (commonly used for anti-inflammatory purposes) and have anti-inflammatory effects in isolation


2Pharmacology

2.1. Enzymatic Interactions

A study assessing interactions of Devil's Claw with P450 noted interactions with CYP3A4 (IC50 values of 124.2-327.6µg/ml) and PXR (EC50 values of 10.21-169.3µg/ml), neither of which were attributable to Harpagoside or Harpagide and the potency deemed of minimal concern for drug-drug interactions.[21]

One study noted that Devil's Claw extracts (commercial blends) was able to inhibit P-Glycoprotein as assessed by an accumulation of Calcein-AM in cells (accumulation of which is indicative of P-gp inhibition) with an EC50 value between 262.4-303.6μg/mL; significantly weaker than the reference drugs Vermapril (5.1μM), Celecoxib (8.3μM), and Nimesulide (20.4μM).[22] This was wholly unrelated to the Harpagoside content, which was inactive.[22]


3Neurology

3.1. Mechanisms

A phenylethanoid (PE) fraction from Devil's Claw appears to have cholinesterase inhibiting properties (crude extracts ineffective), and may increase acteylcholine levels secondary to this.[12] This study noted that, in vitro, the PE fraction inhibited acetylcholinesterase in a concentration dependent manner from 50-200ug/mL (56.87-73.17% inhibition) and butrylcholinesterase, where the latter had complete inhibition with the cell suspension PE extract (50-200ug/mL; 93.16-100.0%) and nearly complete with the hairy roots PE extract (100-200ug/mL, 86.52-90.66%) and outperformed Galantamine as the active control.[12] Isolated Verbascoside (main phenylethanoid in Devil's Claw) showed dose dependent inhibition on both enzymes, but could not account for the majority of inhibition (reaching 47.94% and 39.19% inhibition at 200ug/mL respectively).[12]

3.2. Pain

Traditionally, a root powder has been given at doses of 250mg thrice daily to pregnant women to alleviate pain.[3]

When assessing pain reducing effects, 30-300mg of Devil's Claw extract dose dependently reduced pain (as assessed by formalin-induced liking and biting) in mice. The degree of licking/biting was reduced 18.1 and 27.1% in the first phase (100 and 300mg/kg respectively) and 42.5% and 59.0% in the second phase.[23] The pain reducing effects were similar in the second phase to Grape Seed Extract (which was ineffective in the first phase) and more potent than that of Hypericum perforatum; Devil's Claw appeared to be mediated by opioidergic mechanisms as it was partially abolished by Naxolone.[23]


4Inflammation and Immunology

4.1. Mechanisms

An ethanolic extract of Devil's Claw in activated monocytes is able to dose-dependently reduce the release of proinflammatory cytokines TNF-α, IL-6, PGE2, and IL-1β with significance at 100mcg/mL or above, and nearly abolishing TNF-α release at 500mcg/mL; the IC50 being thought to be slightly lower than 100mcg/mL.[24] p38 MAPK and JNK were unaffected (and NF-kB, usually a mediator, was uninvolved), but AP-1 binding to the genome was abolished at 100-200mcg/mL in both monocytes and macrophages[24] with similar reductions in cytokines at 500mcg/mL being replicated elsewhere.[25] Harpagoside may be active in this regard as it in isolation has been linked to both inhibition of Nitric Oxide (NO)[26] and the release of inflammatory cytokines (200uM).[25]

These anti-inflammatory effects have been noted in a whole blood assay where COX-1 and COX-2 were inhibited to roughly similar degrees and nitric oxide release attenuated; the potency correlating with Harpagoside content.[27]

Appears to inhibit AP-1 from influencing the genome, and thus prevent the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines in response to inflammatory stressors. Harpagoside itself may be active, but other constituents appear to contribute

In regards to the Irioid Glycosides, most appear to be either inactive or relatively weak in inhibiting macrophage respiratory burst although 8-O-(p-coumaroyl)-harpagide is moderately effective with an IC50 of 32µM,[2] a mechanism that has been noted elsewhere with Triterpenoids in inhibiting Neutrophil respiratory burst.[8]
Several bioactives appear to lessen the activity of respiratory (oxidative) burst, which may underlie antiinflammatory and antioxidative properties

4.2. Cartilage and Joints

A study in rabbits fed 150mg Devil's Claw extract (14% Harpagoside; said to correlate to 200mg Harpagoside for humans) for six months after unilateral medial meniscectomy and transection of the anterior cruciate ligament (surgery to damage cartilage) noted that control rats had 30% reduction in cartilage thickness in the operated knee relative to control knee; the group fed Devil's Claw had a less difference, but it did not reach statistical significance.[28] A letter to the Editor (of the journal Phytomedicine[29]) discussing this rabbit study noted that Haematoxylin and safranin staining of the joints showed a trend towards increased cartilage regeneration while elastin stainings reached statistical significance, and that mRNA levels of TIMP-2 were increased a variable 2-5 fold higher than control.[29]

One study in rabbits has quantitatively assessed cartilage repair rates with Devil's Claw, and came back negative (a trend to inducing repair, but was not statistically significant)

4.3. Osteoarthritis

When looking at rat studies, arthritis induced by injections of M. butyricum had the paw edema significantly reduced by oral administration of 50mg/kg Devil's Claw (50% ethanolic extract) but was less potent than the active control of prednisone at 10mg/kg.[25] This builds off a previous study where 100mg/kg of a 60% ethanolic extract was able to abolish the increase in edema induced by Freund's Adjuvant (research toxin to induce arthritis) and showed dose dependence at 25 and 50mg/kg.[30]

Contrasting that data is one study where 2g/kg Devil's Claw outright failed to exert anti-inflammatory effects in response to M. butyricum or lambda-carrageena induced arthritis.[31] This study does not mention sourcing of the Devil's Claw, and was 11 days in duration (whereas more recent studies in rats are longer in duration[25][30]).

In rats, it appears to reduce inflammation in models of arthritis. The potency does not appear to exceed that of reference drugs (Prednisone) when tested

Numerous observational studies exist (minimal controls) to suggest benefit to osteoarthritis associated with Devil's Claw, with 8 cited in one meta-analysis[32] but minimal available online. This review as well as a few others[33][34] note that the evidence is promising but minimal.

For studies available online, one study using the brand name product Doloteffin (2400mg Devil's Claw standardized to 60mg Harpagoside) over 8 weeks noted improvements on symptoms of Osteoarthritis (hip, lower back, and knee) as assessed by WOMAC, Arhus low back pain index, and a modified HAQ;[35] Benefits were apparent in 50-70% of persons, with more benefit being seen in older persons of those with worse disease pathology.[35] Another study conducted over 6 weeks using the same dose of Doloteffin noted that the reduction in pain was comparable to 12.5mg Rofecoxib (COX2 inhibitor),[36] and when patients of this study are given Doloteffin for a year afterwards the pain reduction seems to reach peak efficacy around 30-60 days and then persist at the same magnitude[37] although other sources cite it may take up to 4 months to realize maximal benefits from Devil's Claw.[38]

Surprisingly little evidence available online, but there appears to be a large amount of trials published in German not available via Medline (with one meta-analysis citing up to 10 studies unretrievable via search engines[32]). Devil's Claw appears to be effective for chronic pain, either weaker or comparable to reference drugs (of which comparative trials are minimal)


5Safety and Toxicology

5.1. General

Traditional usage of Devil's Claw appears to be somewhat limited, with warnings of cancer with overconsumption (definition of what 'cancer'; is to traditional medicine is quite vague) and criticism from tradtional users that modern medicinal usage may be overusing Devil's Claw.[3]

In rats, the LD50 has been said to be above 13.5g/kg bodyweight (with this study mentioning preclinical trials conducted in their lab[31]) with this study also citing that 7.5g/kg of Devil's Claw orally for 21 days failed to significantly alter serum parameters measured.[31] These doses, in human estimated equivalents, are 2.16 and 1.2g/kg bodyweight.

A meta-analysis of human evidence looking at the safety of Devil's Claw[32] notes that in trials of Osteoarthritis that around 10% or less of persons report side-effects, which are of mild severity up to high oral doses (8100mg basic extract). The most common side-effects are gastrointestinal (flatulence and diarrhea) with some reports of headaches and migraines likely related to Devil's Claw intervention.[32] Dyspepsia has also been reported.[32] This meta-analysis also cited a lack of long term evidence.

Some sources state that traditional usage advises against long-term usage, there is inadequate evidence to address this concern currently; short term usage does not appear to be associated with any significant side-effects aside from possible gastrointestinal disturbances

5.2. Pregancy

Traditional usage of Devil's Claw involved topical solutions applied to the belly of pregnant women to ease pain and more commonly used postpartum to alleviate pain, yet alternatively high oral doses were said to induce birth or expel placentas.[3] When investigating this claim, high concentrations (200-1000ug/mL) of the extract in isolated uterine muscles can induce contractions in both pregnant and non-pregnant rat uterine strips.[39]

Due to traditional usage for expelling placentas and preliminary evidence saying that Devil's Claw can induce uterine contractions, usage of Devil's Claw should be avoided during pregnancy

Scientific Support & Reference Citations

References

  1. Akhtar N, Haqqi TM Current nutraceuticals in the management of osteoarthritis: a review . Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis. (2012)
  2. Qi J, et al Iridoid glycosides from Harpagophytum procumbens D.C. (devil's claw) . Phytochemistry. (2006)
  3. Mncwangi N, et al Devil's Claw-a review of the ethnobotany, phytochemistry and biological activity of Harpagophytum procumbens . J Ethnopharmacol. (2012)
  4. Barnes J Devil's claw (Harpagophytum procumbens). Also known as 'grapple plant' or 'wood spider' . J Prim Health Care. (2009)
  5. Devil’s Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens): An Anti-Inflammatory Herb with Therapeutic Potential
  6. Chrubasik S Addendum to the ESCOP monograph on Harpagophytum procumbens . Phytomedicine. (2004)
  7. Clarkson C, et al Identification of major and minor constituents of Harpagophytum procumbens (Devil's claw) using HPLC-SPE-NMR and HPLC-ESIMS/APCIMS . J Nat Prod. (2006)
  8. Qi J, et al Isolation and anti-inflammatory activity evaluation of triterpenoids and a monoterpenoid glycoside from Harpagophytum procumbens . Planta Med. (2010)
  9. Boje K, Lechtenberg M, Nahrstedt A New and known iridoid- and phenylethanoid glycosides from Harpagophytum procumbens and their in vitro inhibition of human leukocyte elastase . Planta Med. (2003)
  10. Karioti A, et al Analysis and stability of the constituents of Curcuma longa and Harpagophytum procumbens tinctures by HPLC-DAD and HPLC-ESI-MS . J Pharm Biomed Anal. (2011)
  11. Study on Chemical Constituents in Tuber of Harpagophytum procumbens D.C
  12. Georgiev MI, Alipieva K, Orhan IE Cholinesterases inhibitory and antioxidant activities of Harpagophytum procumbens from in vitro systems . Phytother Res. (2012)
  13. Georgiev M, et al Bioactive metabolite production and stress-related hormones in Devil's claw cell suspension cultures grown in bioreactors . Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. (2011)
  14. Iridoid and phenolic glycosides from Harpagophytum Procumbens
  15. Munkombwe NM Acetylated phenolic glycosides from Harpagophytum procumbens . Phytochemistry. (2003)
  16. Homova V, et al Devil's claw hairy root culture in flasks and in a 3-L bioreactor: bioactive metabolite accumulation and flow cytometry . Z Naturforsch C. (2010)
  17. Phytochemical and flow cytometric analyses of Devil’s claw cell cultures
  18. Clarkson C, Campbell WE, Smith P In vitro antiplasmodial activity of abietane and totarane diterpenes isolated from Harpagophytum procumbens (devil's claw) . Planta Med. (2003)
  19. Clarkson C, et al Discovering new natural products directly from crude extracts by HPLC-SPE-NMR: chinane diterpenes in Harpagophytum procumbens . J Nat Prod. (2006)
  20. Babili FE, et al Anatomical study of secondary tuberized roots of Harpagophytum procumbens DC and quantification of harpagoside by high-performance liquid chromatography method . Pharmacogn Mag. (2012)
  21. Modarai M, et al The interaction potential of herbal medicinal products: a luminescence-based screening platform assessing effects on cytochrome P450 and its use with devil's claw (Harpagophyti radix) preparations . J Pharm Pharmacol. (2011)
  22. Romiti N, et al Effects of Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens) on the multidrug transporter ABCB1/P-glycoprotein . Phytomedicine. (2009)
  23. Uchida S, et al Antinociceptive effects of St. John's wort, Harpagophytum procumbens extract and Grape seed proanthocyanidins extract in mice . Biol Pharm Bull. (2008)
  24. Fiebich BL, et al Molecular targets of the antiinflammatory Harpagophytum procumbens (devil's claw): inhibition of TNFα and COX-2 gene expression by preventing activation of AP-1 . Phytother Res. (2012)
  25. Inaba K, et al Inhibitory effects of devil's claw (secondary root of Harpagophytum procumbens) extract and harpagoside on cytokine production in mouse macrophages . J Nat Med. (2010)
  26. Huang TH, et al Harpagoside suppresses lipopolysaccharide-induced iNOS and COX-2 expression through inhibition of NF-kappa B activation . J Ethnopharmacol. (2006)
  27. Anauate MC, Torres LM, de Mello SB Effect of isolated fractions of Harpagophytum procumbens D.C. (devil's claw) on COX-1, COX-2 activity and nitric oxide production on whole-blood assay . Phytother Res. (2010)
  28. Wachsmuth L, et al Micro-morphometrical assessment of the effect of Harpagophytum procumbens extract on articular cartilage in rabbits with experimental osteoarthritis using magnetic resonance imaging . Phytother Res. (2011)
  29. Chrubasik JE, et al Potential molecular basis of the chondroprotective effect of Harpagophytum procumbens . Phytomedicine. (2006)
  30. Andersen ML, et al Evaluation of acute and chronic treatments with Harpagophytum procumbens on Freund's adjuvant-induced arthritis in rats . J Ethnopharmacol. (2004)
  31. Whitehouse LW, Znamirowska M, Paul CJ Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens): no evidence for anti-inflammatory activity in the treatment of arthritic disease . Can Med Assoc J. (1983)
  32. Brien S, Lewith GT, McGregor G Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens) as a treatment for osteoarthritis: a review of efficacy and safety . J Altern Complement Med. (2006)
  33. Gagnier JJ, et al Herbal medicine for low back pain: a Cochrane review . Spine (Phila Pa 1976). (2007)
  34. Brendler T, et al Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens DC): an evidence-based systematic review by the Natural Standard Research Collaboration . J Herb Pharmacother. (2006)
  35. Chrubasik S, et al Comparison of outcome measures during treatment with the proprietary Harpagophytum extract doloteffin in patients with pain in the lower back, knee or hip . Phytomedicine. (2002)
  36. Chrubasik S, et al A randomized double-blind pilot study comparing Doloteffin and Vioxx in the treatment of low back pain . Rheumatology (Oxford). (2003)
  37. Chrubasik S, et al A 1-year follow-up after a pilot study with Doloteffin for low back pain . Phytomedicine. (2005)
  38. Thanner J, et al Retrospective evaluation of biopsychosocial determinants and treatment response in patients receiving devil's claw extract (doloteffin) . Phytother Res. (2009)
  39. Mahomed IM, Ojewole JA Uterotonic effect of Harpagophytum procumbens DC (Pedaliaceae) secondary root aqueous extract on rat isolated uterine horns . J Smooth Muscle Res. (2009)