Study under review: Effects of soy isoflavones on cognitive function: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
It’s a pretty safe bet that most people want to improve their cognitive functioning. There are at least two ways of doing so: by improving cognition from a healthy baseline, and by preventing diseases that reduce cognitive health. There is a chance that isoflavones derived from soy could do both.
Isoflavones are bioactive compounds found predominantly in soy products. They are considered phytoestrogens because they are natural, plant-derived (hence the Greek root “phyto-”) molecules that exhibit estrogen-like action in the human body. It is important to note that their estrogenic activity is comparably low and whether they increase or decrease (competition) estrogen signaling depends on environmental factors.
However, isoflavones’ estrogenic activity could be important for enhancing cognition, since estrogen receptors are found in pretty high quantities in two important brain areas: the hippocampus, which plays a major role in memory formation, and the prefrontal cortex, which is where a lot of higher reasoning capacity takes place. The theory that isoflavones can improve cognitive function has been bolstered in mouse models, where isoflavones have been shown to improve aging- and drug-related memory problems in otherwise healthy mice.
There is also reason to suspect that isoflavones could help ameliorate cognitive decline related to disease. This is because they have been shown to exert anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects, as well as anti-apoptotic (programmed cell death) effects in mitochondria. Preclinical studies have shown that soy isoflavones have the ability to remove amyloid beta and decrease tau phosphorylation in Alzheimer’s disease models. All these reported benefits would seem to explain reported improvements in cognitive function associated with soy isoflavone intake in humans, but the verdict remains inconclusive.
Some studies report positive associations between soy isoflavones and cognitive function, suggesting their use to combat cognitive decline in elderly people, while one study did not report any influence and suggests differences in metabolism or basal levels of estrogen as important factors. Systematic reviews of RCTs have also reported both positive and no effects. One meta-analysis reported a very small effect, but did not include all studies available.
The authors of the study under review conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to determine the influence of soy isoflavones on overall and domain-specific cognitive functions. They also evaluated the adverse effects of soy isoflavones reported.
Soy isoflavones have demonstrated actions that support cognitive function in animal studies, but human studies have yielded rather conflicting results. The authors of the study under review designed a meta-analysis with the aim of resolving the conflicting results.
Other Articles in Issue #62 (December 2019)
NERD Mini: The Arthritis Foundation’s recommendations concerning CBD for arthritis
We distill the main recommendations concerning CBD's use in arthritis from this patient advocacy group.
Is halving red and processed meat intake heart healthy?
While this study is highly exploratory, it suggests that red and processed meat could impact women's and men's cholesterol levels differently.
NERD Mini: Higher vitamin E levels may increase the risk of coronary artery disease and heart attacks
Given oxidation's role in plaque development, antioxidants like vitamin E should be heart healthy in theory ... but theory doesn't always pan out.
Grazing is for cows, not for people with type 2 diabetes
Three meals a day, starting with a large breakfast, helps people with diabetes maintain better glycemic control compared to smaller meals throughout the day.
Beyond metformin: long-term lifestyle modifications seriously cut diabetes risk
Diet and exercise makes a major dent in the rate of type 2 diabetes development for people at risk.
Getting salty over heat stress
How does salt intake impact the human body when exercising in a high heat, low humidity environment? This study explored the issue.
Spicing up depression: curcumin as an adjunct therapy
This meta-analysis found that curcumin has a huge impact when added to antidepressant therapy. There are a few reasons to interpret these results cautiously, though.