Study under review: Cranberry Reduces the Risk of Urinary Tract Infection Recurrence in Otherwise Healthy Women: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are the most common urologic disease among women in the U.S., occurring in 102 out of every 100,000 women. You can see how the rate varies with age in Figure 1. While rarely fatal, UTIs cause tremendous discomfort and result in a large financial burden on the healthcare system, at roughly $2.6 billion in annual health care expenses.
Standard treatment for UTIs involves the use of antibiotics, a treatment strategy that substantially increases the risk of antibiotic resistance. Furthermore, fluoroquinolone antibiotics may have serious side effects, such as tendon rupture, leading the FDA to advise that they should not be used for uncomplicated infections, including uncomplicated UTIs. These issues with antibiotics have given researchers reason to look for other methods for preventing UTIs. For decades, the idea has circulated that cranberry juice can treat or prevent UTIs, and some evidence from clinical trials suggests that this idea is more than a old wives’ tale, although the evidence for UTI prevention is more robust than for treatment.
In addition to clinical evidence, there is some mechanistic data to support the idea that consumption of cranberries might reduce UTIs. Cranberries are rich in a compound called proanthocyanidins. Proanthocyanidins have documented antibacterial properties against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Furthermore, administration of proanthocyanidin-rich cranberry powder for six months reduced the risk of UTI by over 50% over 12 months.
Currently, the evidence in the literature regarding the efficacy of cranberry for preventing UTIs is mixed. Two different meta-analyses have shown conflicting findings. The disparate findings are the result of researchers including different studies and having different criteria for analysis. Additionally, the previous meta-analyses examined both complicated and uncomplicated UTIs, the former of which is more serious and is treated very differently in the clinical setting, compared to the uncomplicated variety. Some factors that would make a UTI complicated are shown in Figure 2. Furthermore, these analyses included both men and women, who have dramatically different rates of UTIs. The present study is a systematic review and meta-analysis that was designed to cut through some of the issues present in the previous meta-analyses and evaluate the evidence concerning cranberry’s ability to prevent uncomplicated UTIs in otherwise healthy women.
UTIs are the most common form of urologic disorders and occur frequently in women. UTIs are often treated with antibiotics, some of which can have serious side effects, and many of which can lead to antibiotic resistance over time. Cranberry, due in large part to its high levels of proanthocyanidins, may be a viable non-antibiotic approach to preventing recurring uncomplicated UTIs among women.
Other Articles in Issue #39 (January 2018)
Mini: Coffee Correlations
It can be hard to keep track of all of the health claims made for coffee. A 2017 umbrella review helps suss out what benefits and harms are associated with coffee intake.
Interview: Beth Skwarecki
In this interview, with Lifehacker health editor and writer Beth Skwarecki, we discuss the unique challenges of communicating the results of scientific studies to the general public, and more.
You may be sleeping, but your muscles don’t have to!
As men age, it becomes harder for them to maintain muscle mass. Can an overnight dose of protein help improve muscle protein synthesis in older men, even in the absence of exercise?
Caffeine tolerance kills its benefits
The evidence for caffeine habituation's effects on its ergogenic properties has been mixed. This trial adds to the evidence by going for longer and not relying on self-reported caffeine intake.
Is research on beta-alanine still in beta?
Beta-alanine is thought to help decrease muscle fatigue through boosting intramuscular carnosine levels. This systematic review aimed to look at the state of the evidence for its efficacy.
Investigating sodium bicarbonate for better endurance performance
Bicarbonate supplementation has mostly been tested for high-intensity exercise. But does it help for lower-intensity aerobic performance?
Selenium supplementation for heart health: overlooked, unnecessary, or uncertain?
Proteins that need selenium to function help mitigate oxidation and regulate inflammation, processes that play a role in cardiovascular disease. Can supplementation with selenium help?